| Alfred | Siena | |
| 24 - 0 (forfeit) | 4 - 6 | |
| 1 | Coleman | Carassi |
| 2 | Keeler | Keeler |
| 3 | E Heltz | E Heltz |
| 4 | Sweeney | Sweeney |
| 5 | Jamison | Jamison |
| 6 | Culhane | Culhane |
| 7 | Carty | Carty |
| 8 | Bruce | Bruce |
| 9 | Stofer | Stofer |
| 10 | Sion | Sion |
| 12 | Milne | Milne |
| 13 | Lane | Groth |
| 11 | Chuppe | Kowalski |
| 14 | Terech | Terech |
| 15 | Calabrese | Calabrese (4) |