| IUP | Slippery Rock | U Pitt | |
| 0 - 29 | 9 - 5 | 8 - 34 | |
| 1 | Race / Barney | Tillou | Barney |
| 2 | Agnello | Agnello | Agnello |
| 3 | Blaser | Blaser | Blaser |
| 4 | Pribish | Pribish | Pribish / Tillou |
| 5 | Tubridy | Tubridy | Tubridy |
| 6 | Kinch | Kinch | Kinch |
| 7 | Urbaniak | Urbaniak | Urbaniak |
| 8 | Falgiano | Race | Race |
| 9 | Stickle | Falgiano | Falgiano |
| 10 | Moscato | Moscato (333) | Moscato (3) |
| 12 | Clancy | Clancy | Clancy |
| 13 | Tomsic | Tomsic | Tomsic |
| 11 | Molnar /Hoffman | Molnar | Molnar |
| 14 | Quintieri / Ocrah | Quintieri/Hoffman | Ocrah (5) |
| 15 | Snyder | Snyder | |